7 Comments
User's avatar
Salman's avatar

My fave line: "So what was once tacit and implicit came to be made explicit through a difficult and painful process." this feels like it is one of those important types of wisdoms which is always true, even if we don't want it to be.

Expand full comment
Caroline Howard's avatar

A fascinating topic. I’m looking forward to reading more about this.

Expand full comment
Bryan Kam's avatar

Thanks so much for reading Caroline! I'd love to hear any questions if you have them.

Expand full comment
Caroline Howard's avatar

I'm interested to know exactly how Durkheim's anthropological research challenged the idea of logic as absolute. What kind of research did he do?

Expand full comment
Caroline Howard's avatar

Also, I loved the analogy with Athena bursting forth from Zeus's head.

Expand full comment
Nina Schuyler's avatar

Thank you! I wondered how this view of logic as not absolute but changing aligns with Hegel and his historical view of the evolution of consciousness.

Expand full comment
Bryan Kam's avatar

Hi Nina! Thanks so much for the question. I have to admit I have not yet looked deeply into Hegel, but my sense is that he will provide a bridge between Rousseau and Marx, Feuerbach, and Nietzsche, all of whom see consciousness as changing over time. I started to look into an ancient thread too (Hesiod, Genesis, Lucretius) but haven't finished that thinking yet :) Do you know if Hegel discusses logic in Phenomenology of Spirit?

Expand full comment